Choosing an Executor in Ontario: Why the Person You Trust Most Is Not Always the Best Choice

General-information disclaimer: This article provides general information about Ontario law and is not legal advice. Legal outcomes depend on the specific facts. Obtain advice about your own situation.

In Ontario, the person commonly called an executor is generally the estate trustee named in the will. The job can involve locating assets, protecting property, dealing with financial institutions, applying for an estate certificate when required, filing taxes, paying debts and distributing the estate.

Trust is essential, but the role also demands time, organization and judgment.

A realistic scenario: what can go wrong without advance legal planning

The following is a fictional/composite scenario created for education.

A parent appoints the eldest child because that seems traditional. The child lives overseas, travels constantly and has a difficult relationship with the other beneficiaries. After death, practical delays and communication problems make the administration far harder than the parent expected.

What you should know

1. Trustworthiness

The estate trustee controls sensitive information and significant property. Integrity is non-negotiable.

2. Availability

The job can last months or longer. Someone with no time or who lives far away may still serve, but practical complications should be considered.

3. Organization

Estate administration produces records, deadlines, tax filings, banking and correspondence. Good record keeping matters.

4. Family dynamics

A person who is likely to inflame existing conflict may not be the ideal choice, even if trusted personally.

5. Skill and professional help

The trustee does not need to know all estate law, but should know when to obtain legal, tax, appraisal or investment advice.

6. Alternates

A will should usually name an alternate in case the first person cannot or will not act.

Practical checklist

  • Ask the person before naming them.
  • Consider geography and family relationships.
  • Name at least one alternate where appropriate.
  • Leave organized asset and contact information.
  • Review the choice every few years.

The practical lesson

The best estate trustee is not determined by birth order. Choose the person most likely to administer the estate carefully, fairly and practically.

Get help before the issue becomes urgent

Thomas, Efraim LLP can review executor appointments as part of a free Will and Powers of Attorney review or estate-planning consultation.

Relevant Thomas, Efraim LLP pages

Scroll to Top